A Post About a Terrible Book that Sarah Darkmagic is Reading and How it Was a Total Pick-me-up for Me

I don’t normally read Sarah Darkmagic’s blog, not because it’s not a good blog, but because almost all of the posts are hella depressing and focus almost exclusively on what’s wrong in gaming rather than what’s good in gaming. Y’know, like if every post I wrote was like the one that briefly put me at odds with the BFRPG community… Color me cynically privileged, but it’s exhausting to care that hard all the time!

But I actually found myself reading one of her recent posts, and one of the things she highlighted was an exchange in a book that she was reading:

Why did you kiss me?”

She started to answer, but R’s expression turned dark and he continued, “What did you hope to gain from it?”

D fell back another step, but then came forward aggressively, dropping her blade and putting her hands on her hips. She stood barely inches from R staring at him coldly.

“You cannot be mad at me!” R insisted.

“You have shown me– you have taught me! You have taken me to those noblemen’s grand parties and shown me how to use your charms to mainpula–”

D’s hand came up faster than R could react and slapped him hard across the face.

She huffed and swung around to run away, but R caught her by the shoulder and tugged her back around, throwing himself at her. And when they crashed together, he hugged her tightly. He saw the moisture in her pretty brown eyes, and kissed her.

She twisted to get away. She pulled her mouth back. But R pressed in harder and rejoined the kiss and D’s tension gradually melted away, and then she was kissing him as passionately or more.

“Do you doubt me?” she asked, and she twisted suddenly, dropping them both to the floor, her atop him.

“Have you never kissed any of them? Isn’t that part of the game you play?” R asked.

She did not mention the name of the author, and obscured the work by not naming the characters involved, but mentioned that he/she was a popular author, also wrote young adult fantasy, and, in above passage, was contributing to the Rape Culture. She complained about how she had to force herself to finish it for reasons that she only vaguely alluded to.  I think that she missed a wonderful opportunity to name and shame. I mean, I wanna know who this dude is. No, not because it contributes to Rape Culture or offends my sensibilities, but because of how freaking bad it is! Oh, my god! This is what I have to compete against as an aspiring fantasy writer? Color me optimistic! I now feel like the stuff I’ve been churning out isn’t half bad, so maybe I have a chance!

I would like to know who this author is so I can avoid him/her like the plague, but thank you, Sarah Darkmagic, for showing me just how low the bar is really set for Popular Fantasy. Considering that the only ‘fantasy’ book I’ve read recently has been by Umberto Eco, I thought I was fucked, cuz that guy is amazing and I could probably NEVER be that good. But this

He felt the fool for ever doubting this amazing halfling lass. She was playing no game for him; her feelings were honest.

made me feel really good about myself as a writer in that even the stuff I wrote in high school was not that awful. Maybe there’s hope for me yet!


Turns out it’s by R.A. Salvatore!  Really!?!  BWAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!


3 responses to “A Post About a Terrible Book that Sarah Darkmagic is Reading and How it Was a Total Pick-me-up for Me

  1. I knew there must have been a reason I never read that like, one book I have that he wrote. Srsly.

    On a related note, reading Johnny the Homicidal Maniac is what really got me moving to write my own comic. That piece of crap got him a job offer from Nickelodeon, I figured what the heck.


    • I actually missed out on the whole Johnny the Homicidal Maniac thing when it was big when I was in high school. My girlfriend has a copy that I thumbed through the first few chapters, and really I found that a lot of it was shocking platitudes masquerading as ‘deep thought’ and social commentary. I can totally get why teenangsters dug it, but now that I’m pushing 30, there’s not really anything there to grip me.

      I’ve always wanted to do a comic. I can’t draw, but I’m I’m a halfway decent script writer. Unfortunately, things usually have fallen apart on the art end for one reason or another, so I’ve never gotten anything past the pre-production phase. The last thing I worked on was a really ambitious dystopian sci-fi that was heavily inspired by Kerberos Panzer Cops, but it didn’t get beyond concept art and half a dozen issues worth of scripts.

      • As I’m sure you’ve seen from my site, I wrote and illustrated a pixel art comic that ran for daily for 16 months. I can draw but I don’t really have a “drawing habit,” and I didn’t have the patience to develop one alongside my writing, which is why I ultimately went with pixel art.

        I’ve written a couple novels but nothing yet that I’m willing to publish or even submit for editing. After the last one I realized I needed to work on pacing and plot development, which are the skills I’ve been working on over the last couple years (since NaNoWriMo 2011 actually).


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s