Hugo Review: Ms Marvel Vol. 1


This is very much a teenager with problems story. Not bad for what it is, but not a superhero story. She has to deal with racists and her traditional parents for a lot of slice of life stuff before we get to anything exciting and heroic. It’s VERY slow in comic terms, taking an entire issue before she becomes Miss Marvel. Then there’s a lot of introspection before anything exciting happens, and what we do get is fairly low-stakes.

Ms Marvel feels, in its art, its story and its pacing, like an indie comic dressed up mainstream Marvel title. You cannot go into Miss Marvel hoping for a superhero comic; you will be disappointed. It’s a pretty good slice of life + aww, man, I’m a teenager with superpowers, but it’s not a good superhero comic. So depending on how you’re assessing it, it’s going to be either great or terrible. Sometimes I feel like it’s trying too hard to be hip and relevant, but that’s a common crime in mainstream comics so is easily forgiven. Slightly more annoying is the very strong Dorky Sue wish-fulfillment vibe going on to the point where if I didn’t know that Kamala was actually Ms Marvel, I’d be waiting for the part where she wakes up and it’s all a dream. Then again, knowing Marvel, that’s always a possibility.

Ms Marvel is not message fiction: that terrible Batman and the Outsiders Annual #1 where the Outsiders fight the Force of July, a villain team put together by a straw-republican who read 1984 and decided that what we need is more government, was message fiction. It’s more teen-girl drama where getting superpowers that one can’t control is a metaphor for growing up while you’re trying to figure out who you are.  It’s never really ham-fisted and, unlike other recent titles, exists to explore and push new creative boundaries rather than to troll comic book fans.  So yay, for that!

I’ll admit that I’m not really familiar with a lot of the Marvel properties, and that includes previous incarnations of Miss Marvel, so I can’t really compare Kamala to any earlier versions. Her main power seems to be over the size of portions or the whole of her body with limited transformation related healing. The giant hands power is kinda creepy and weird looking. She’s kind of a glass cannon at this point, which could make for some interesting hero-villain combat dynamics in the future, but that isn’t really explored very much in volume 1.  Kamala lacks an interesting or compelling villain, which is a driving force behind so many of the best heroic origin stories; her self-doubt could be said to be the villain of volume 1.  Plenty of heroes struggle with self-doubt, but they tend to do so while fighting really interesting bad guys.  Kamala has a guy with a weird bird costume show up on the very last page of the volume promising things have only just begun.

Like I said, this one is a slow burn – a real slow burn – and there’s practically no bang at the end. Despite that, it’s something I wouldn’t mind reading more of. Still, I have a hard time being convinced that this is the best comic book story of 2014; it might be, I don’t know, since I don’t read Marvel, swore off DC’s New 52 and don’t read indie stuff as much as I used to. I don’t know where I’ll place this one in the ranks yet. It’s definitely not a lock for 1st, but if someone asked me if Miss Marvel was a good comic, I’d probably tell them “Yeah, it was alright. I liked the old Runaways better, but you could do worse.”

3 responses to “Hugo Review: Ms Marvel Vol. 1

  1. Pingback: Everyone is Talking About Month Old Crazy | Cirsova

  2. I like Jim Zub’s Wayward. I think in one of the interviews he may have mentioned liking Saga.

    Naruto ended last year, and could’ve qualified. It’ll probably also qualify for this year. The climax of Naruto is essentially a fist fight, which ties the story together thematically and stuff.

    • Hmmm, I just looked up Wayward. I like the art in that better than any of this year’s noms. I started on Saga Vol 3, but I’m having a hard time getting into it. Largely because I’m jumping into the middle of it, I expect. Can’t really say that I’m a fan of Naruto; I don’t have the hate-on for it that most people who know it but aren’t fans tend to have, but knowing that that’s a thing I think its chances would’ve been pretty slim. There are few titles as polarizing as Naruto.

      But yeah, if there are any collected volumes of Wayward, I’ll probably check and see if the first one is at the library or something and give it a read.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s