The Empire Strikes Back is a Terrible Sequel and Obi-Wan Kenobi is the Worst Dude in the Galaxy

I ended up getting enough spoilers for the Force Awakens that I was not so interested as to beg my family to put off seeing it a few days while I was out of town.  I’ll probably end up seeing it the way I saw Attack of the Clones – via the Red Letter Media Review.  But when I was still thinking I might see it over the holidays, I went back and rewatched the original trilogy*; there are some things that really stick out like a sore thumb!

Before you get too mad, re-read the title.  Note that I don’t say it’s a terrible movie, but a terrible sequel.  Okay, so why do I say Empire is a terrible sequel?  Because in the context of what we know about Star Wars from a New Hope, it barely makes any sense.  I’ll get to the gaping plot holes in a minute, but let’s start with the biggest problem: George Lucas’ twist that he knew was coming all along but really didn’t which retroactively makes Star Wars make less sense.

Empire begins with Vader looking for Skywalker.  He’s all “Growl, I sense young Skywalker is with the rebels!  Moogah boogah!”  All of a sudden, Vader knows who Luke is and is looking for him.  In New Hope, Vader didn’t know him from Adam, and there was no indication that he actually realized who was flying the X-wing that blew up the Death Star.  He merely notes that the force was strong with this one, the way the Red Baron might’ve remarked upon the skills of a pilot who dodged his shots in a WW1 movie, but that wasn’t any indication that he even knew that it was the same kid who’d shown up with Ben Kenobi.  If anything, Vader should’ve been holding his grudge for Solo.  Vader sensed Kenobi on the Death Star without a whiff of Luke in New Hope.  In Empire, Vader is like a bloodhound with an old sock.

As Jeffro has pointed out, making Vader Luke’s father makes Obi Wan Kenobi a liar; this is a big deal, but I’ll tackle it after a few plot holes.  The telescoping of time in Empire muddles a lot of things.  We never really get a good idea of how long Luke trains with Yoda.  Is it a day?  A long weekend?  Because we don’t know the distances between Bespin, Hoth and Dagobah, we can’t really say how the characters get places and when.  Though hyperdrive is often referred to as Light Speed in the Star Wars universe, it’s pretty clear that it’s faster-than-light.  How does Vader reach Cloud City before the Millennium Falcon?  Does Boba Fett relay the Falcon’s warp coordinates so that the imperial fleet can re-route and somehow get their first?  Why did they even need to hire Boba Fett, he doesn’t even do anything!?  Why do so many Star Wars fanboys obsess over a background character who dies like a bitch in Jedi?  Anyway, somehow, a single-occupant fighter manages to get from a backwater swamp planet to Bespin in like a day because Luke’s spider-sense was tingling.  The time thing would not be so jarring if I wasn’t constantly reminded of the fact that the entirety of Star Wars: TIE Fighter takes place between the evacuation of Hoth and the order to build a second Death Star.

The iconic light saber fight between Vader and Skywalker introduced one of the many elements that would eventually make the Star Wars universe completely terrible: using the force to throw garbage at each other during a sword fight.  How did I forget about that?

Also, they really dropped the ball on that whole “no, there is another” reveal.  Nothing in Jedi indicates that Leia would’ve been able to stop the trio of evil Luke, Vader and Palpatine.  But that’s on Jedi, not Empire.

Really, though, this post is about Obi Wan Kenobi, so let’s move on to him.


You may have thought the Star Wars Saga is about Anakin or Luke or the Skywalker Family.  You’d be wrong.  Star Wars is about Obi Wan Kenobi the way that the Tale of Heike is about Taira no Ason Kiyomori: it is the chronicle of the destructive and lingering ripples, even beyond his death, of one man’s dedicated craptacularness.  Obi Wan Kenobi is a terrible person and this is the tragic story of the ruination of all he touches.

When we’re first introduced to Obi Wan Kenobi, he is the whimsical moral center and sage of a fairly rote bildungsroman who guides the youth on his path to manhood.  But that’s all tossed out and retconned, largely by Empire and Jedi, but even moreso by the prequels.

Obi Wan tells Luke Vader killed his father.  Empire makes him a liar, and Jedi shows him refusing to own it.  Far worse than the midiclorians is Ghostbi Wan in Jedi coming up with a simpering justification filled with moral relativism as to why he lied.  He doesn’t say “Look, Luke, I lied, I’m sorry” but “In a way I was kind of telling you the truth.”  The one thing that the prequels succeed at is justifying this by showing Obi Wan Kenobi to be a horrible person.

Even though Yoda doesn’t call him on it, Obi Wan lies about being trained by him RIGHT IN FRONT OF HIM!  We never see Kenobi under the tutelage of Yoda but under some mysterious shmuck who would use his Jedi powers to con merchants and cheat at games of chance.  Obi Wan spends most of the prequels being an angry and jealous asshole.  We can conclude that he was lying even about ever being Anakin’s friend in New Hope based on what we see in the prequels.  The events in the life of Luke Skywalker are set in motion by an elderly Obi Wan Kenobi who clearly sees an opportunity to get back at Anakin AND drag his kids into it.  “Strike me down and I shall become more powerful than you can imagine.”  He’s martyred himself in front of Vader’s kid; Skywalker doesn’t know what a shitty dude Kenobi is, so naturally it will polarize him against Vader.  I’m also pretty sure that Yoda didn’t want Luke to know about his sister because it would lead Vader to her; hardly seems a coincidence to me that Kenobi lets it slip RIGHT AFTER YODA DIES!  Kenobi, knowing that Luke’s sister is alive, is going to make sure that Vader and Palpatine have leverage against Luke.  What a guy!

Obi Wan as the overarching villain of the Star Wars saga may sound like some “Ron: the Deatheater” shit, but go back, watch the movies and think about it: IT MAKES TOO MUCH SENSE!  The problem is that it’s ENTIRELY ACCIDENTAL!  You know you’ve made a huge mistake when the character you’ve tried to make the moral anchor of your story is so wafflingly written that his being a villain is more than just plausible.

Anyway, big announcements and reveals tomorrow.

*:VHS Original edition.

9 responses to “The Empire Strikes Back is a Terrible Sequel and Obi-Wan Kenobi is the Worst Dude in the Galaxy

  1. I agree–“Empire Strikes Back” made me lose all interest in the Star Wars franchise when it came out. (Mostly, I’ll admit, because I hated Yoda.)

    The new one, though, I thought was really excellent, and I do recommend seeing it in the theater.

    • I have so many mixed and complicated feels about Star Wars. It had moved well into its second phase of cultural phenom when I was a kid; though they’d all come and gone before I was born, they were being shown on TV every year at holidays, and LucasArts game studio was at its height. TIE Fighter was just so unbelievably awesome, and even if the whole Han Solo’s best friend that he never talks about aspect was lame, the Shadows of the Empire N64 game was pretty sweet. Star Wars seemed like the coolest thing ever until Phantom Menace came out and star wars became embarrassing for everyone!

  2. An interesting way of looking at it! That meme made me laugh too.

    I haven’t seen the old ones in a few years, but I can believe that it’s true. It is sad that it’s accidental.

    • Thanks. Yeah, it was something that had never really bothered me until it was pointed out that Empire “made Obi Wan a liar”. Then when I watched that scene in Return of the Jedi, I noticed how uncomfortable Alec Guinness seemed trying to explain how he hadn’t really lied if you looked at it a certain way, and was all “Aww, man, even Alec Guinness can tell this was a bad idea and it hurts him to say these things!”

      • I think comic book artist John Byrne first drew my attention to that. A decade or so ago, he was trying to explain how big of a shock “Obiwan the lying liar” was to audiences at the time. He pointed out how the first Marvel comic to come out after its creative team saw Empire has a stunned Luke trying to work out the implications of it all and he is completely bewildered and flabbergasted. (I don’t see that panel in a Google image search right off.)

      • Really, his doubling down on it in Jedi is what sends it over the edge for me. And he does it at the same time he drops the breadcrumbs that he knows will send Luke straight after Vader and put Leia at risk! What a guy…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s