Review – In Search of Sacha, by Manuel Guzman

Manuel Guzman recently sent us a digital copy of his children’s picture book, In Search of Sacha. With everything we’ve had going on with Cirsova recently [submissions, Wild Stars, and gearing up for 2024], I’ve only recently had a chance to read it, but I wish I had gotten to it sooner, because it was an absolute delight.

In Search of Sacha is a mythopoetic adventure throughout which a father and mother pursue the trail of their missing son through a series of uncanny situations and encounters with the realm of faerie.

The story is written in present tense, which I’m usually against, but it works for this sort of picture book, where the action is shown side-by-side with the narration.

The art is gorgeous, with luscious scenes full of intricate detail worth pausing on and studying. Paired with the mythic language, it creates an evocative mood, both melancholy and hopeful.

The text is a little advanced: this is one that you would want to read to and with your kids, as it could be very challenger for younger readers. The story is a little longer and denser than the typical picture book, so it may even need to be broken up into chunks.

My only real complaint about the book is the lettering. I think it could benefit from a second edition with improved lettering–a bolder typeface with either border stroke or appropriate glows/dropshadows for readability. In several places, the white lettering against brighter backgrounds and the black lettering against darker backgrounds fade out of legibility and detract from the overall quality of this book.

As a standalone work, there is room for improvement on the overall presentation, though there is still much to recommend it. As a portfolio piece, In Search of Sasha is stunning, showcasing a wide range of both portraiture and dynamic artwork.

Manuel Guzman’s various sites and social media can be found through his linktree here.

Thoughts on Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End

Over the long weekend, I started watching the meme elf anime, and it’s pretty good!

Rather than look at the typical story of the adventuring party that goes, fights the evil, triumphs, and returns, Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End is from the perspective of the titular elf who, as an immortal, is destined to outlive her adventuring party. Following the funeral of the party’s fighter, she realizes that she took for granted the people in her life; what was just a moment for her was a lifetime to the people around her. After the party’s cleric tricks her into taking an orphan girl he adopted on as her apprentice on his deathbed, Frieren retraces her original journey to get a feel for the people she missed out on getting to truly know. It’s a very touching and sentimental story; kind of a tear-jerker, even.

One of the few criticisms leveled against it has been that its fantasy world is “generic,” and it doesn’t really try to put any twists or ackshuallys into its worldbuilding.

Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End strikes me a deconstruction of the kinds of occidentalist fantasy, such as Lodoss War, that sprang up in Japan from its exposure to D&D devoid of D&D’s actual inspirational literature.

The concept of a “generic western fantasy” setting is something that really didn’t emerge until the 80s, when people were familiar with fantasy through D&D and similar games but were growing unfamiliar with the literature that originally inspired them.

In Japan, you had a unique situation where they got that glimpse of that kind of fantasy and ran with it while having an almost total literary disconnect from the western fantasy canon.

Series like Slayers or Those Who Hunt Elves come across like a pisstake on the “more serious fantasy” of Lodoss and Lodoss-like fantasy while actually falling more into alignment with pre1980s fantasy literature.

What I’ve enjoyed about Frieren is that it plays the “serious fantasy” straight while looking at the elements of those settings through a more critical and analytical lens, rather than just aping the Lodoss for aesthetic.

Rather than seeking to add clever new twists, Frieren is a critical analysis of themes and elements taken for granted by most occidentalist [and occidental] fantasy.

A few people have noted how much it feels like oldschool Western fantasy fiction, but I kind of disagree. I think that it only works because of the Japanese cultural background. It has a very “floating world” vibe that it uses as its lens to analyze a Lodoss-like setting from the perspective of a character who some have noted is very much like Ginko from Mushishi. It’s really kind of an existential meditation on mortality, the passage of time, generational transitions and how tradition can connect the past to the present.

The funny thing is, if you didn’t know better, going from the online fandom, you’d think it was more like FairyTail or something than what it actually is. [People are extremely thirsty for that autistic elf]. But Frieren is WholesomeTM [at least through the 8 or 9 eps I’ve had time to watch] and a brilliant bit of sentimental fantasy fiction with some gorgeous art, animation, and storytelling.

Review – The Wizard of Lemuria

Finished reading my first Lin Carter book. It wasn’t terrible [I had been prepped for terrible, given his rep], but the thing that struck me most was how much like an Alex Toth saturday morning cartoon it felt. It didn’t waste time on nuance, characterization, or complication, which was almost refreshing.

For example, I kept expecting the Wizard to pull a fast one [cuz that’s what wizards do, right?]. Nope, Wizard is a solid bro through the whole thing with only one tease the he could’ve possibly betrayed Thongor. Disgraced Captain of the Guards guy who joins after Thongor is captured by the Druids is mostly along for the ride and there to be an extra sword. Cute princess is a bland, competent ingĂ©nue who only has eyes for Thongor once she’s rescued.

Thongor himself is good-natured, affable, competent; his main flaw besides bad luck is that his good-naturedness and sense of personal justice get him into scraps such as the one that kicked off his quest.

The plot never gets tangled into more than one complication at once, with each resolved quickly before the next step of the fetch-quest Thongor and the Wizard go on. Occasionally, Thongor gets separated, but everyone’s always back together in time for the next plot point. There’s not the sort of sense you get from Burroughs where you wonder how everyone is going to finally get through everything and back to one another by the end of the story.

But hey, that’s fine!

I don’t know how many of these I could be bothered to read, but this one was pretty fun for what it was.

Special thanks to Schuyler Hernstrom who sent me this in a paperback care package several years back. Sorry I’m just now getting to this one!

Don’t forget, the Winter Issue of Cirsova comes out next month, and we also still have Cirsova 2024 Calendars for sale!

Winter 2023 Issue Available for Pre-Order + New Merch Available!

This is it! The 30th Issue of Cirsova Magazine!*

eBook is available for pre-order on Amazon. Once the Lulu proofs arrive, we’ll send mailing list subscribers early access purchase links on Lulu for the hardcover and softcover.

There’s also new merch in the merch store.

What does the Winter Issue hold in store?

Moonlight Over Sussex
By DANIEL J. MINUCCI
Nick’s crew were a solid heist team, but their successes have caught the attention of the Czar! Now they’re being taken out one-by-one by the Czar’s unstoppable goon!

Commander
By RICHARD MARTIN
The CSS Albemarle blocks the approach to Plymouth via the Roanoke! Can Lt. Cushing’s crew pull off a daring night mission to sink the Confederate Ironclad?!

Ithuriel’s Spear
By JOSEPH W. KNOWLES
A boy has vanished, completely without a trace! The only clue that Marshal Clive Moultrie has is a medicine man who has newly arrived in a nearby pueblo village!

Incident in Burma, 1942
By MARK ARVID WHITE
A British Indian unit is holed up in a temple, hoping to evade Japanese patrols! But are the strange nightmares plaguing the men worse than their foes in the jungle?

That Hideous Brain
By JEFFERY SCOTT SIMS
Sterk Fontaine specializes in acquisition of certain occult artifacts… But Frampton Derosch, who seeks the Eye of Xenophor, may be his most dangerous client yet!

Rising Shadows
By ADAM S. FURMAN
John Knox is on the trail of a particularly nasty demon! Following it leads him somewhere rather unexpected, however… to the Reverend of a megachurch!

Red Queen’s Race
By PAUL LUCAS
Rab is running out of time! His Financial Seconds are ticking away until his body is reclaimed! Can his high-powered Brain OS and cybernetic personal assistant Alice get him through the day, or will high costs and rising prices cost Rab his life?!

The Gold Exigency
(Part 4 of 4)
By MICHAEL TIERNEY
The God Father is dead! Conrock and company are in the fight for their lives on Philea as pirates and Black Star Reavers close in on them… Can they save the Phileans from extermination in the name of the Artomique’s monetary policy?!

The Redemption of Alness
By JIM BREYFOGLE
On the verge of victory over Rhygir, Kat’s army has been destroyed by Fedai reinforcements! Rhygir has barely enough troops to hold Alness, but Kat is missing! The saga of the Mongoose and Meerkat concludes in this final chapter!

*:10 issues of Volume 1 + 17 issues of Volume 2 + 3 “Specials”

Spring 2023 Issue Free This Week!

To celebrate 4k followers on twitter, we’re giving away digital copies of the Spring 2023 issue!

Wild Stars VII is wrapping up in the magazine next month, so you’ll have a chance to get started if you missed the first installment.

Speaking of, Orphan of the Shadowy Moons funded on Kickstarter! We’re putting the order for the proofs in now.

Also, don’t forget that the Cirsova 2024 Calendar is on sale now!